Television interview - News24 First Edition

  • Transcript, E&OE
Subjects: Tax reform; Australia-ETU FTA; Small business support; PM’s comments.
16 November 2026

Peter Stefanovic, host: So, let's bring in Matt Thistlethwaite, Zoe McKenzie on this Monday morning. Matt, I'll start with you because trusts is interesting. Bran Black has now doubled the tax take expectation, $900 million to $1.7 billion. Have you undercooked things again?

Matt Thistlethwaite, Assistant Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade: We don't believe we have, Pete. Tackling inflation, providing cost of living relief for Australians is our priority. And the trust legislation is an important part of that policy suite to achieve those aims. It's about equalising the taxation system. The average Australian nurse or teacher, hospitality worker, they can't divert their income into a trust to avoid paying their fair share of tax. So, we're making the taxation system much fairer and equalising it for all Australians and to ensure that they pay their fair share of tax. We reckon we've got the compliance cost right. Less than 10 per cent of businesses are affected by this and we're providing an important opportunity for small businesses over the next couple of years to restructure without triggering a capital gains tax incident that will trigger that tax. And the states are providing the stamp duty relief. So, there's an opportunity there for businesses to restructure which reduces those compliance costs.

Stefanovic: Well, let's go to you, Zoe, because you've got Chamber of Commerce, Business Council, Property Council, housing, industry, all those key stakeholders, they've put a letter forward urging senators to block this legislation. But it's pretty key, I would have thought, from Bran Black here, to suggest that the tax take is now doubling. This is what happens when you consult.

Zoe McKenzie, Liberal Member for Flinders: Indeed, this is what happens when you listen to people, something that maybe this government ought to have done before its budget in May. But the really important issue is this. If you listen to what Matt has said, and equally if you listen to what the Treasurer says, what they want is everyone to live a life like they're a worker for someone. If you're the poor person who puts their hand up to start a business, to take risk, to probably take on debt against your family home, to try and strive to build and grow that business, to provide employment for other people, to change the prosperity and the journey possibly of your community because you're creating something new in that community, then this government hates you, this government wants to crush you and this government wants to rip another $1.7 billion out of your pocket. We need to be really, really the differences on the sides of parties of government, because, frankly, it's never been starker. These guys want one size fits all journey through life. You're an employee and you're paying regular tax. You're not the risk taker. You're not the growth agent. You're not the person who wants to try and create opportunities for others. That person, that woman, that man, they're in real trouble with this government.

Stefanovic: Sounds like socialism, doesn't it, Zoe?

McKenzie: Well, and the rest, yes.

Stefanovic: So, over to you, Matt. Won't this just hamper investment? Because why would you invest if there are more roadblocks?

Assistant Minister: Pete, can I just respond? That's complete rubbish.

Stefanovic: Which bit is rubbish?

Assistant Minister: The other big thing that we're trying to do is the EU Australia Free Trade Agreement. The point that Zoe's trying to make there is complete rubbish because this week we're trying to negotiate the Australia EU Free Trade Agreement, which supports Australian small businesses and opens up one of the largest consumer markets in the world to Australian small businesses and big businesses, indeed in the consumer market, in our farmers, in critical minerals, the mining sector. So, many Australian businesses will benefit from this and we're trying to open that up a new market for Australian businesses. The Coalition is opposing it. So, you're opposing Australian businesses getting access to growth opportunities in one of the largest consumer markets in the world. If you want to talk about not supporting Australia's small businesses, then there's a classic example of it from the Coalition.

Stefanovic: Well, we'll go back to that in just a moment. But onto trusts. I mean, you're hampering investment here by increasing the taxes. So, aren't you providing more roadblocks for investors?

Assistant Minister: At the same time, we're providing relief for Australian small businesses with instant asset write off with rollover relief associated with these changes. Yes, they are difficult changes, we know that, but we're providing as much support for Australians --

Stefanovic: Yeah, but have you done your proper homework though? Because this is a pretty big miss. I would have thought if Bran Black ends up being right, that the tax take ends up being double. I mean, how do businesses trust what you're doing?

Assistant Minister: Well, we're confident in the assessments that have been made and the consultations that we're having with Australian small businesses. And that's what this is all about, working with to reduce those compliance costs. That's why we've been able to work with the states to ensure that there's no stamp duty on any Australian businesses that restructures out of the current system. So, we work with Australian businesses, but we're the ones that are trying to prioritise them getting access to one of the largest consumer markets in the world and growing their bases.

Stefanovic: Well, let's get back to that point then to you, Zoe. I mean, you've got this conversation that's apparently taking place today between Don Farrell and Matt Canavan. I mean, is this going to lead to the Coalition supporting what Don Farrell and the government's doing?

McKenzie: So, again, let me slow down on this one because it's an important issue. The EU FTA is indeed heading towards the Australian Parliament. Matt was using some interesting terminology today to say it's been negotiated. Well, the negotiations between Australia and Europe were concluded earlier this year when Ursula von der Leyen came to Australia. What will happen from here is it'll go to the Joint Standing Committee on Treaties, probably earlier next year and be properly interrogated. Now, what we have said all the way along is that we are absolutely in favour of an agreement with Europe, 450 million people, our second biggest destination, sorry, source of foreign investment. It is absolutely vital that there is a high-quality agreement with Europe. Europe is unlikely in the future to do massive deals of the nature it's done with Australia, including agriculture, because it's getting harder and harder for them to do it. And we've watched our friends across the ditch in New Zealand see, sign and conclude and put their agreement into effect last year. And a 34 per cent increase in export. We want that too. The problem with this deal is it has a kind of whoopee cushion clause relating to climate change and the Paris Agreement. There are multiple interpretations of what it means. On one level, it says you are stuck with what you've put in, what this Labor government has said you're going to do in relation to net zero that we know is crippling the Australian economy. But on another reading, all it says is if you withdraw from Paris, there's a problem, but whatever else you want to do as a sovereign nation within the confines of Paris is absolutely fine. Now, that was said by Sean Kelly, who is in charge of the Parliamentary Friends of Australia in the European Parliament last week in our papers. So, there's some evidence that that's what Europe thinks. And our point is, if that's what you think, if that's what you believe, if we are completely sovereign to do whatever we want in relation to climate change, but for leaving Paris, which, by the way, Angus Taylor and Matt Canavan have said we will not be doing, if we are sovereign in relation to climate change policy, then write it down, tell us that, give us some confidence. Ted O'Brien has been very clear about that and in fact, he's speaking to a conference today in Canberra saying that. Again, I'm sorry, it's complicated, but it's important to explain it. We are in favour of an agreement with Europe. Just a better one than the one that this government landed.

Stefanovic: Something that's a little less complicated. The Prime Minister apologising for his crude talk with Chris Bowen. Zoe, what do you make of that?

McKenzie: I know, right, so we've got poo lies last week in relation to the Marrickville Golf Club and then we've got dick jokes this week. Honestly, if he goes to China later this week and makes another melon joke, I think we're done. But frankly, he said sorry this time. I suppose that's progress.

Stefanovic: Okay, we'll have to leave it there because I got to go to a break. Matt and Zoe appreciate it. We'll talk to you again next week. We are off to a break.

Media enquiries